2 Corinthians 8:10
Intermediate2 Corinthians 8:10 · World English Bible (WEB)
“I give a judgment in this: for this is expedient for you, who were the first to start a year ago, not only to do, but also to be willing.”
Tip: highlight any word or phrase above to go deeper on exactly that.
Overview
Paul’s pastoral counsel about completing a previously begun act of generosity.
Paul is not issuing a harsh command but giving Spirit-shaped judgment for the Corinthians’ good: they had eagerly begun the collection for the saints a year earlier, and now it would be fitting and profitable for them to finish what they had both desired and started.
What Makes This Verse Confusing?
Paul distinguishes this counsel from a direct command. In the surrounding passage, he says, “I speak not by commandment” and then gives his judgment. This does not make the verse uninspired or optional in a careless sense; rather, the Holy Spirit gives us Paul’s apostolic wisdom for a situation involving voluntary generosity. The gift must be sincere, not coerced.
The verse does not restate the contrast from the surrounding context between command and counsel, so “judgment” can sound like a merely private opinion if read in isolation.
This shows that Christian giving is not meant to be extracted by pressure. God honors willing obedience, and Paul shepherds their willingness rather than forcing their hand.
Cultural & Historical Context
The Corinthian church, a gifted but often unstable congregation, was being urged to complete its promised contribution for suffering believers.
Paul was organizing a collection among Gentile churches for impoverished saints, especially connected with the believers in Jerusalem. The Corinthians had shown eagerness earlier, but their follow-through had lagged.
- ✦Such a collection required deliberate setting aside of resources over time. Paul’s concern is that the gift be completed willingly and honorably, not gathered through last-minute pressure or embarrassment.
Theological Insights
Godly generosity joins willingness and completion; holy desire is meant to mature into faithful action.
Believers should take seriously the good intentions God has stirred in them, especially when those intentions involve mercy, generosity, and care for the saints.
Original Language
resolution — γνώμη , -ης, ἡ (γιγνώσκω), [in LXX: Da TH 2:15 (דָּת), Ps 82(83):3 (סוֹד), elsewhere, chiefly II Es, for טְעֵם ;] __1. a means of knowing, a token (Theogn.). __2. In Attic writers, the mind , its operations and results (see Edwards, Lex. , App. , A); __(a) mind, understanding ; __(b) purpose, intention : Act.20:3; __(with) judgment, opinion : 1Co.1:10 , Rev.17:13 ; __(d) counsel, advice : 1Co.7:25…
This word for “judgment” carries the sense of considered counsel or discernment. Paul is not weakening the Word of God; he is giving apostolic wisdom suited to voluntary giving, where compulsion would violate the very grace he is cultivating.
be profitable — συμ-φέρω [in LXX: Jer.33:14 (טוֹב), Pro.19:10 (נָאוֶה), Sir.30:19 , al. ;] __1. trans. to bring together: with accusative of thing(s), Act.19:19. __2. Intrans., and mostly impers., συμφέρει, it is expedient, profitable or an advantage : 1Co.6:12 10:23 , 2Co.8:10 ; with inf. (M, Pr. , 210), Mat.19:10 , Jhn.18:14 ; with dative, before ἵνα (Bl., § 69, 5), Mat.5:29-30 18:6 , Jhn.11:50 16:7 . Ptcp., ςυ…
The word behind “expedient” points to what is beneficial or profitable. Paul’s concern is not only the need being met but the spiritual good produced in the givers when they complete what grace began.
to begin beforehand — προ-ενάρχομαι to begin before : 2Co.8:6; with accusative, τὸ θέλειν, 2Co.8:10 (not elsewhere).† (AS)
This word stresses beginning beforehand. The Corinthians were not being asked to start from nothing; they were being called to finish a work already begun, making the verse especially about follow-through.
Lexicon & word tagging: STEP Bible (Tyndale House, STEPBible.org, CC BY 4.0)
Related Passages
Hebrews 13:16
Background1 Timothy 6:18-19
Background2 Corinthians 9:2
parallelPaul later says he knows their readiness and had boasted about it, saying Achaia had been ready since the previous year.
James 2:15-16
parallelJames warns against words of compassion that do not become practical help for a brother or sister in need.
Proverbs 19:17
Background1 Corinthians 7:25
Background1 Corinthians 16:2
backgroundPaul had previously instructed the Corinthians to set aside something regularly for the collection.
1 Corinthians 7:40
BackgroundCross-references from the Treasury of Scripture Knowledge · openbible.info (CC-BY)
How This Applies Today
This verse speaks directly to delayed obedience in generosity: promises, burdens, and good intentions should be brought before the Lord and completed with integrity where He has given ability.
- →Identify any act of generosity or mercy you began or intended but have left unfinished, and take the next concrete step to complete it faithfully.
- Has God stirred willingness in me that I have not yet carried through into action?
Key Takeaway
Paul’s counsel is that the Corinthians should finish the generous work they eagerly began, because completed obedience is spiritually good for them.
Grace-born willingness is beautiful, but it is meant to become finished obedience.“
Analysis generated on September 25, 2026 · version 2.0
Support DeeperBible
If this analysis helped you understand Scripture better, consider buying me a coffee to keep the site running. 100% free, forever.
☕ Buy Me a Coffee